Subscribe now and get the latest ICT news to your inbox for free!    
Telecom Franchise in Nigeria - Yusuf Sanni.
Nigeria is more than  ripe for e-banking services - Woherem.
NIGCOMSAT-1
Telecoms around the world.
Africa.
Nigeria.
Computing and Networking.
Pathway to a rewarding IT career - Julius Ayuk Tabe.
Advert Rates / Subscription
 
Archive
April 2008 Edition
         
...read now
 
April 2008 Edition
         
...read now
 
March 2008 Edition
         
...read now
 
October/November 2007 Edition
         
...read now
 
Connecting rural communities in Nigeria has continued to be a source of grave concern to stakeholders in the telecoms industry in the country especially as efforts are being intensified to bridge the digital divide between her and the rest of the developed nations of the world. A new business mode- Franchising is being advocated as the most suitable for accelerating this connection. The big question is Can it Work in Nigeria? YUSUF SANNI attempts an answer.
  With the successful launch of the Nigerian Communications Satellite-1 (NIGCOMSAT-1), the first of its kind in sub-Saharan Africa, expectations are high in the air that communication services in Nigeria; the continent’s most populous nation will dramatically improve for the better.
These expectations are not unconnected with the benefits derivable from this kind of project. Communication experts say that the satellite will improve telecommunication services including voice telephony and data. Bandwidths for Internet services are also expected to provide more satisfactory services as against what is presently obtained.However, the ultimate beneficiary of this new project is rural Nigeria, which has been avoidably neglected in the provision of
 

telecommunication services. Even with the country’s teledensity growing to over 30 million, the impact is yet to be felt in rural Nigeria.
The World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS), which held between November 16, and 18, 2005 in the North African city of Tunis in Tunisia, was to review the implementation of the ambitious agenda earlier set at the WSIS Geneva Summit held in 2003.

The Geneva Summit saw over 174 countries adopting a Declaration of Principles outlining a common vision of the information society and a plan of action that sets targets to improve connectivity and access in information and communication technology use.

The Summit expects that the targets that have to be met include and not limited to connecting villages, community access points, schools and universities, research centers, libraries, hospitals, as well as local and central government departments.

The International Telecommunications Union (ITU) had in a report said that the 942 million people living in the world’s developed economies enjoy nine times better access to Internet services than all other people in developing regions. Yet, in ITU’s estimate, over 800,000 villages still lack connection by telephone line, the Internet or any other modern ICT.

 
The rate at which the Internet for instance is penetrating communities in developing nations is very slow. In Nigeria for example, with an estimated population of 140 million people, only an insignificant number of people is said to have access to the Internet. Yet, the Internet has

become the hub of business in today’s world, driving the economies of nations.From all indication, Nigeria seems to be lagging From all indication, Nigeria seems to be lagging behind going by the WSIS initiative. Government’s poor handling and funding of ICT projects has also helped in no small way in widening the gap between the country and digitalized economies of the world.

In 2006, two different summits were held in the continent of Africa to map out strategies on how to plot the continent’s path to the actualization of the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) of the United Nations despite challenges of access to ICT services. Both summits were held in Abuja, Nigeria and Cape Town, South Africa, respectively. Abuja had earlier hosted the Digital World Conference 2006 where yet strategies for bridging the digital divide between Africa and the rest of the advanced world were plotted.

A critical look at all the summits held in 2006 point to the fact that Africa appeared to have suddenly discovered its rear position in efforts at accelerating communication access in the world.
This could perhaps too, underscore the rationale behind a recent stakeholders forum organized by the Association of Telecommunication Companies of Nigeria (ATCON) in conjunction with the Nigerian Communication Commission (NCC) to find the easiest way of accelerating efforts at bridging the digital divide separating Nigeria from other advanced nations of the world.

The forum provided the organizers a platform to look at the prospects of adopting franchise and virtual network operation as means of accelerating telecom services in Nigeria in general and rural Nigeria in particular.
Franchise according to Oxford Advanced Learner’s Dictionary is a formal permission given by a company to somebody who wants to sell its goods or services in a particular area.

Those pushing for accelerated communication access in Nigeria hold the opinion that unless urgent proactive measures are taken to address the communication plights of the underserved rural Nigeria, efforts at bridging the digital divide would come to naught. They insist that the provision of communication services in Nigeria has been concentrated on urban areas at the detriment of the rural populace.

  At the ATCON- organised one day Telecom stakeholders’ forum with the theme: Telecom Franchise and Virtual Operation: Accelerating Service Provisioning in Rural Nigeria, president of the association, Dr. Emmanuel Ekuwem, said the forum was intended to “critically examine the possibility of using franchising and virtual operation to increase telecom access in the rural areas in Nigeria”.
Minister of State for Communications, Dr. Femi Anibaba who was represented by a director in the ministry, Dr. Umar Ningi implored operators to be mindful of the challenges that lie on the way to the provision of services in the rural areas adding that efforts at accelerating service provisioning in rural Nigeria can only succeed if the language the rural dwellers understand, is used.
Co- organizers of the event, the Nigerian Communications Commission

(NCC) ostensibly worried by the slow pace at bridging the digital divide in Nigeria through a seamless access to communication services noted that it decided to collaborate with ATCON for the forum largely because of the sub-theme which focused attention on accelerating service provisioning in rural Nigeria.
Executive Vice Chairman (EVC), Engr. Ernest Ndukwe, who was physically present at the event to probably show how worried he was observed that though a lot has been achieved in the area of increasing teledensity in Nigeria, it remained a naked fact that many parts of the country were still unbelievably lacking telecommunication services.

Ndukwe reiterated the Federal Government’s commitment to ensuring that all parts of Nigeria were linked to the global communications infrastructure maintaining that as a primary ICT policy implementation agency of the Federal Government, the NCC “is resolute about doing whatever is necessary to ensure we achieve universal coverage where no part of this country in the next five years will be without communications network coverage”.

A tall dream this may be but going by Ndukwe’s track records since he assumed office as the Commission’s helmsman, participants at the event seemed not to take that promise with a pinch of salt.

Ndukwe went further to say that his agency was interested in the coverage that would provide access not only to basic voice communications, but also to broadband and Internet adding that his Commission recognized the fact that this coverage will be built by private operating companies in line with the policy of government to position the private sector as the engine of growth for the economy.

The NCC had initiated various programmes such as the Wire

Nigeria (WiN) programme and the State Accelerated Broadband Initiative (SABI), all targeted at accelerating access in both urban and rural areas. These are in addition to the Universal Service Provision Fund (USPF) established to provide funding specifically for rural, underserved and unserved areas The mission of the regulator to the event he said was to listen to stakeholders’ suggestions, ideas and proposals that it intends to study and determine how best to support access to rural Nigeria through franchising and virtual operation.

He observed that this would give impetus to the Commission’s primary focus of seeking ways to promote investment that will lead to growth in subscriber lines as well as a variety of service offerings for consumers.

  The NCC chieftain who admitted that franchising operation as a business model is gaining global acceptance with cases of large operating companies contracting equipment manufacturing companies to Build, Operate, Maintain and Own network infrastructure, hoped that the proposed model for Nigeria will be on a smaller scale where an entrepreneur sets up a network in an identified underserved area in cooperation with a major licensee.

Ndukwe did not exit the stage without some nagging questions for participants: Who takes responsibility for consumer issues in terms of protection, enquiries, complaints etc? Who takes responsibility

for equipment type approval and site approval? Would the franchise company require an operating license from the NCC?
Virtual Network Operation (VNO), Ndukwe noted needed some level of studies to determine whether the market is mature enough and ready for operators even as he raised question on the need for a Virtual Operator when Nigeria operates a fully liberalized market.

The EVC sought to know whether the regulator should be bothered with a licensing category that is a Virtual Operator License in a technology- neutral environment, where the regulator does not get involved in how the operators build their networks and which equipment suppliers they choose. “Could it be that the concept of licensing VNOs is out of date in today’s world in the light of the fact that operators are already encouraged to share infrastructure?” he asked.

Engr. Ndukwe however, left his audience with this poser: Does the Virtual Network Operators need regulatory intervention to be successful or do they possess sufficient appeal to be attractive to Network Operators?

That was the beginning of the debate on how to use franchising and virtual network operation to accelerate the provision of communication to rural dwellers in Nigeria. Fola Odufuwa, an Executive Director with eShekels Nigeria, a foremost telecom research firm who came in as a lead presenter remarked that it may look like an irony but Nigeria still ranked highest in the patronage of telecom-related materials in the world even as it is considered a poor nation.

Research has proved that contrary to widely held belief; rural dwellers were interested in mobile phones as those in urban areas. “There is high demand for communication in the rural areas. The problem however, is access and not poverty”, according to Odufuwa.

Odufuwa who insisted that a lot of opportunities abound in rural Nigeria questioned the possibility of Virtual operation succeeding in the country without the requisite infrastructure in place. He might be talking about epileptic power supply and lack of communication facilities like broadband, which have all hampered speedy penetration of communication services in the country.

While making case for franchising as a suitable model, Odufuwa said it has the advantages of creating the ability to speedily start a new business based on proven template; ability to expand operations more rapidly across the nation and the creation of higher volumes based on national branding.

The eShekels Executive Director admitted that even in the face of these advantages, are issues that would confront its success. Some of these he said, include loss of control on the part of franchisee, delay in attaining synergy and building trust and commitment among the two parties as well as doubts in the competence of the franchisee.

He noted that franchising could help grow the Nigerian telecom industry by way of replaying the profit synergies evident in other market sectors like the Retail food services and the petroleum outlets.

“In addition, it will reduce the market- distorting gap between the big players and their extremely small counterparts. It will deepen SME capacity and increase the growth of local entrepreneurs and their enterprises”.  
  Franchising in telecom in Nigeria according to Odufuwa is novel and to some extent, could be unique to the country but would require innovative thinking to be practicable and effective.
For this business model to succeed in Nigeria, he said proper legal framework as well as telecoms policies that would promote fair access, right of way and public safety services, should be put in place. “Nigerian entrepreneurs do not really need subsidies. They rather want a level playing field, access to capital, fair access to existing networks and adequate profit sharing structure as well as adequate legal protection for their investments”, Odufuwa concluded.

Perhaps when this business model takes off eventually, the agency that would provide the necessary support would be the Small and Medium Enterprises Development Agency of Nigeria (SMEDAN), headed by Mrs. Modupe Adelaja.

The Director-General observed that by facilitating rapid communication, telecoms has turned the world into a global village.” Good telecoms services is necessary for national economic growth as it encourages investment, creates employment opportunities, serves as a veritable alternative to transportation as well as a major business tool.

The SMEDAN chief remarked that bridging the communication gap especially in rural areas has been met with some difficulties arising from SMEs’ poor access to finance and non-attractiveness of rural investment in telecoms by big time investors. Adelaja opined that the fastest and easiest way of reaching the rural areas was through franchising; an option she argued would present a lot of benefits to the parties involved.

While appraising the growth of the telecoms industry in Nigeria, the Director- General noted that both telecoms and SMEs are mutual catalysts for the growth of each other and therefore, recommended franchise as a business model for the fast delivery of telecom service in rural Nigeria.

The SMEDAN chief executive was not alone in this proposition if what the president of Association of Licensed Telecommunications Operators of Nigeria (ALTON), Engr. Gbenga Adebayo was to say later is anything to go by. Adebayo boasted the business model would facilitate better interface with rural dwellers. “The Franchisee is one of them, he is someone they know he lives with them, and speaks the same language with them.” He suggested that for this to be effective,

operators should appoint local agents to operate Customer care and Friendship help centres adding that agency like the Universal Services Provision Fund (USPF) could help in this regard.
According to him,” The USPF can assist local businessmen with the start-up capital, whilst operators provide the necessary equipment and training under a franchise agreement.”

Adebayo advocated a Build- Operate and Transfer (BOT) method maintaining that engaging the villagers in the business would be essential, as this would guarantee safety of the telecom equipment deployed in such area.

Insisting that operators need to address certain issues before deploying services in the rural areas, Adebayo listed tax relief, granting of pioneer status for the first two operators in defined rural geographical zones, lowering of annual operating levy for services based in rural areas as well as concession on import duty as some of the issues that would require proper attention.

 
So satisfied with the issues raised at the event which tend to lend support to the proposal for the introduction of Telecom Franchise as a business model for growing access in the country, Chief executive officer of the Universal Services Provision Fund (USPF),Lolia Emakpore on whose shoulders lie the responsibility of ensuring communications services access in the country agreed entirely that her agency will do everything in its power to facilitate the take-off of telecom franchise in Nigeria as this was the only way the communication gap in the rural areas could be bridged.
  But even as this proposal appeared to be the easiest means of facilitating speedy telecom access in the country, there are other stakeholders who believed the country was not yet culturally matured to adopt that business model. In fact, some of them argued that it would be wrong to adopt that model here on the basis that it is already the model in areas like Europe and America.
This school of thought contends that the average Nigerian entrepreneur is so self- centred, crude and brutish that he wouldn’t want to share his profit with any other person especially his competitor. This alone could pose as a big challenge to the realization of this dream as profit sharing formular could as well abort the franchise agreement.
These fears may perhaps explain why notable telecom engineers at the Lagos Forum including Engrs.Bayo Banjo and Titi Omo-Ettu as well as Lanre Ajayi, president of the Nigerian Internet Group were united in agreeing that industry regulator, the NCC, would have to apply some tight sanctions and framework that would effectively check violators of the provisions that will see to the eventual take-off of this business model.
Besides, in spite of the success recorded in the retail food services sector where this model has been tried, opinions were that the government, the regulatory agency and other bodies concerned with the development of this
 
model should embark upon adequate enlightenment and sensitization campaign. Now that
  expectations are high that the Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC) would possibly give this model the required legal teeth, it is left to be seen how this model will succeed in Nigeria’s telecom sector if indeed the challenges posed by accelerating seamless access should be tackled head-on. The next couple of months will provide the answer.
   
| Home | News | e-Business | Computing & Networking | Telecoms | Broadcasting | About Us | Contact Us |
Copy right © 2007: Compumetrics Solutions Limited: - Website designed by PBG Communications Limited, Tel: 234-803-312-8335;234-1-814-0524 :email-info@pbgcommunications.com